Vol 1 No 2 (2017)
Articles

On Causal Theories of Proper Names

Published October 10, 2017
Keywords
  • Reference,
  • naming,
  • proper names,
  • causal theory of reference,
  • Evans,
  • Devitt
  • ...More
    Less

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine and critique Evans’ and Devitt’s post-Kripkean theories of naming. I argue that both authors correctly identify a crucial error in Kripke’s causal picture of naming: his claim that initial baptisms are necessary for the reference of proper names. However, I claim that Evans’ theory produces unintuitive results when faced with two problems: the “qua-problem” and the problem of incorrect causal source. I suggest that these issues arise due to his claim that the reference of a proper name is its dominant causal source of information. Finally, I argue that Devitt’s theory deals successfully with these issues by allowing for multiple groundings and by specifying the importance of referring to an object under a correct “kind” term.